The '01 Yanks would show they can capitalize on opportunities as well in the top half of the next inning. Scott Brosius would homer off of '61 Yankee pitcher Bill Stafford, in-and-out of the outstretched glove of Maris, who played the ball wonderfully but could not secure the ball before his arm was jarred against the top of the wall. Maris was applauded for his effort. However, the inning would continue as Mussina hit safely and lead off man Chuck Knoblauch reached on an error by Richardson, who was unable to transfer the ball to his throwing hand. Derek Jeter would hit his second single of the day to score Mussina. Bernie Williams would double to clear the bases and bring the '01 Yankee lead to 4-2.
The bottom of the 5th would see the '61 club pull one run closer with the first of Jeter's costly errors. Back-to-back singles by Elston Howard and Mantle were followed by a scorcher from Maris that took a bad hop on Jeter and would ricochet off of his glove and into the outfield. The return of the '01 Yankees offensive struggles against Stafford set the stage for the bottom of the 8th when the inning led off with another Skowron single. Clete Boyer would single and pinch hitter John Blanchard would also single, scoring Skowron and tying the game. With only one out Tony Kubek would send a ball up the middle for an apparent easy double play and an escape of the inning. Jeter would field the ball cleanly but would send a weak flip behind second baseman Alfonso Soriano, allowing Boyer to score what would be the winning run.
"Those are plays that need to be made and I didn't make them today" said a dejected Jeter after the game. The two errors were part of three that were made by the team and with the offense struggling those are mental errors that can not happen. "The guys in the top and bottom of the order are getting it done. It's our job as the heart of the lineup to bring them home," Tino Martinez, who along with Paul O'Neill and Jorge Posada would go 0-11 with one walk.
"I think it goes to show the will to win in this clubhouse. We play hard everyday and because of that we never feel out of a game," Mickey Mantle, 1-4 2 strikeouts and 1 run, would say of his team. This would be the team's fourth comeback victory of the year while improving to a 6-3 record. The '01 Yankees team would drop their seventh game of the year and move to 2-7 overall.
WP : Bill Stafford
LP : Mike Mussina
S : Luis Arroyo
| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | R | H | E | ||
| '01 New York Yankees | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 4 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 4 | 10 | 3 | ||
| '61 New York Yankees | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 2 | X | 5 | 10 | 1 | ||